Composting instead is less environmentally friendly? This is something 90% of people don't know

Views :

Update time : 2025-06-19

The Dark Side of Composting - You May Be Contributing to Carbon Emissions

In recent years, composting has been widely touted as the ultimate solution to “zero-waste living”. However, the latest scientific research shows that under the wrong conditions, composting can produce more greenhouse gases than landfills.

可用1.png

In 2024, a team of researchers from the University of California, Berkeley, found that:

30% of home composting systems actually increase carbon emissions due to mismanagement

Some “compostable plastics” emit methane (CH₄), which has a greenhouse effect 25 times greater than CO₂, in an oxygen-poor environment.

Part 1: 4 scenarios where composting becomes “high carbon”

Scenario 1: Anoxic composting (methane production)

✅ Healthy composting:

Oxygen is sufficient, microorganisms convert organic matter to CO₂ + water + humus

Carbon emissions: 0.1kg CO₂e/kg compost

❌ Anoxic composting:

Anaerobic bacteria dominate, generating methane (CH ₄)

Carbon emissions: 2.3kg CO₂e/kg compost (23-fold jump)

Common errors:

Compost bin completely sealed

Material too wet and not turned

Scenario 2: Incorrect material mixing (contaminated soil)

Material type Problem Alternatives

Compostable plastics Industrial compost-grade PLA does not decompose at home Recognize OK Compost HOME certification

Meat/dairy Attracts pests, creates odors Bokashi composting only

Herbicides residue plants Poisoning beneficial microorganisms High-temperature composting treatment alone

Test case:

A family put “industrial-grade PLA” tableware into the compost pile and six months later microplastic residues were detected, contaminating the entire batch of compost. A family composted “industrial grade PLA” tableware, and after 6 months, microplastic residues were detected, contaminating the entire batch of compost.

Scenario 3: Low temperature composting (cannot inactivate pathogens)

Ideal temperature: 54-65°C (lasts for 3 days to kill pathogens/weed seeds)

Reality:

Small compost bins are only 30-40°C

Undecomposed pathogens enter the soil with the compost

Research data:

Soil Association tests in the UK have shown that 42% of home composts contain E. coli in excess of the limit.

Scenario 4: Centralized treatment over long distances

Centralized composting plant:

Trucks are needed to transport the waste, generating 3.2kg CO₂ per tonne

Decentralized local composting:

Carbon emissions are reduced by 80%

Typical case study:

A city has introduced centralized composting of food waste, but because of the long distances involved in transporting the waste, the carbon footprint has exceeded that of landfill.

可用2.png